PHA vs PLA vs Starch-based Biodegradable Plastics: Which One Should You Choose?

Three biodegradable polymers—PHA (Polyhydroxyalkanoates), PLA (Polylactic Acid), and starch-based plastics—serve as critical alternatives to petroleum-based materials in the global effort to reduce plastic waste.

PHA

Microbial Fermentation

Produced through bacterial fermentation of sugars or oils. It offers the most versatile biodegradability profiles in natural settings.

PLA

Plant-Based Starch

Synthesized by fermenting plant starches (corn/sugarcane) into lactic acid. Renowned for clarity and high rigidity in packaging.

Starch-based

Agricultural TPS

Thermoplastic starch (TPS) made from potato, corn, or wheat. The most economical option for low-cost disposable items.

Key Properties Comparison

Property PHA PLA Starch-based
Biodegradability Soil, Freshwater, Marine (6-18 months) Industrial Composting (3-6 months) Industrial/Soil (3-12 months)
Tensile Strength 20–40 MPa 50–70 MPa 10–30 MPa
Heat Resistance Up to 120°C 55–65°C Below 100°C
Est. Cost (USD/kg) 4–6 USD 2–3 USD 1–2 USD
Best For Medical, Marine use Food service, 3D printing Mulch films, Carry bags

Decision Framework

1

Exposure to Natural Environments?

If the product risks entering oceans or rivers without industrial composting, PHA is the most suitable option for reliable degradation.

2

Primary Constraint is Cost?

For high-volume production, Starch-based is the starting point. Choose PLA if clarity or stiffness is required.

3

Mechanical & Thermal Stability Needed?

If moisture resistance and heat tolerance are essential, PHA provides the most balanced performance profile.

4

Visual Clarity or Surface Finish?

PLA delivers superior optical clarity and printability for premium consumer packaging.

Deep Dive into Bioplastic Engineering

Ready to make an informed decision? Explore our technical data sheets, lifecycle assessments, and industrial case studies.

Certification Matters

Always verify relevant certifications—such as ASTM D6400 or EN 13432 for industrial compostability, and emerging labels like OK Marine—to confirm environmental performance claims.

ASTM D6400 EN 13432 OK Marine

Summary

Match the material to your specific environmental, performance, and economic requirements. As fermentation efficiency improves, these biopolymers will become increasingly practical across all industrial sectors.

finding the right polymer supplier?

We’re here to help. Don’t hesitate to reach out—we’re ready to support you in building your dreams. Start today and create a better tomorrow.

Related Posts

get in touch